Securities Fraud Investigations: Criminal Defense & Regulatory Representation
When a Financial Investigation Threatens More Than Your Reputation
For investment professionals, financial advisers, executives and business owners, allegations of securities fraud can have consequences extending far beyond fines or criminal penalties.
An investigation may threaten professional registrations, the ability to work in the financial industry, business relationships, personal assets and years of professional achievement.
What makes these matters particularly challenging is that a single set of allegations may lead to several different proceedings. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), state regulators and federal criminal investigators may examine the same conduct from different perspectives.
Resolving one investigation does not necessarily resolve the others.
At The Kreiss Law Firm, our criminal defense and administrative law experience provides a foundation for coordinated representation in matters involving overlapping criminal, civil and regulatory concerns.
We understand the importance of considering not only the immediate allegations but also the potential consequences for a client’s professional standing and future.
Securities Fraud Allegations Can Trigger Multiple Investigations
Securities and financial misconduct investigations may begin with an investor complaint, regulatory examination, unusual trading activity, internal compliance concern or government inquiry.
Depending on the circumstances, allegations may involve:
- Insider trading or the improper use of material nonpublic information
- Investment fraud and alleged misrepresentations to investors
- Market manipulation and improper securities transactions
- Misappropriation or misuse of investor funds
- Misleading financial statements or disclosures
- Unauthorized trading or violations of securities regulations
- Allegations involving investment advisers, broker-dealers or financial services businesses
Not every securities violation constitutes criminal fraud. Some matters involve disputed regulatory obligations, compliance failures or civil allegations without criminal intent.
However, when investigators suspect deliberate deception or other serious misconduct, a regulatory inquiry may develop into a criminal investigation.
Different Agencies. Different Proceedings. Overlapping Consequences.
SEC Investigations and Enforcement Actions
The Securities and Exchange Commission investigates potential violations of federal securities laws and may pursue civil enforcement actions or administrative proceedings.
Depending on the allegations, consequences may include financial penalties, disgorgement, injunctions and restrictions on participating in certain securities-related activities.
The SEC does not prosecute criminal cases itself, but it may refer suspected criminal violations to federal law enforcement authorities.
FINRA Investigations and Professional Registration
For registered securities professionals, a FINRA inquiry or disciplinary proceeding can threaten the ability to continue working in the industry.
Potential consequences may include fines, suspensions, bars from association with FINRA member firms and other disciplinary sanctions.
Certain criminal matters may also trigger disclosure obligations or statutory disqualification issues.
These professional consequences can be substantial even when a criminal prosecution is never initiated.
Florida Securities and Financial Regulation
The Florida Office of Financial Regulation oversees important aspects of the state’s financial services industry, including securities regulation.
Investigations involving suspected financial misconduct may result in administrative or civil enforcement proceedings and, in appropriate circumstances, criminal investigation or referral.
For financial professionals and businesses operating in Florida, state regulatory consequences may need to be evaluated alongside federal proceedings.
Federal Criminal Investigations
Securities-related allegations may also attract the attention of the Department of Justice, FBI or other federal authorities.
Criminal investigations can involve allegations of securities fraud, wire fraud, conspiracy or related federal offenses.
Unlike regulatory proceedings, a criminal prosecution may expose a defendant to imprisonment in addition to financial penalties and other consequences.
Why Coordinated Criminal and Regulatory Defense Matters
The Same Evidence Can Affect More Than One Case
Consider an investment adviser who receives a regulatory inquiry concerning alleged misrepresentations to clients.
The immediate issue may involve documents requested by regulators or questions about particular investments.
But statements, records and explanations provided during that process may become relevant to a separate criminal investigation.
Similarly, a proposed settlement in a civil or regulatory proceeding may have implications for professional registration, disclosure obligations or other legal proceedings.
These connections make it important to evaluate the full scope of a client’s potential exposure before making significant decisions.
A favorable outcome in one proceeding may offer little comfort if it creates serious consequences in another.
The Kreiss Law Firm approaches overlapping legal matters with an understanding of how criminal defense, regulatory enforcement and professional licensing considerations can interact.
Our focus is on developing informed strategies that account for the different proceedings and the client’s broader interests.
Defending Your Ability to Continue Your Career
For many individuals facing securities investigations, professional consequences may be just as concerning as criminal penalties.
A financial adviser, broker, investment professional or executive may have spent decades developing a career, building client relationships and establishing a reputation.
Regulatory sanctions, professional disqualification or restrictions on industry participation can jeopardize that investment.
Depending on the circumstances, an investigation may raise questions about:
- Maintaining securities registrations or professional qualifications
- Continued association with a broker-dealer or investment advisory firm
- Disclosure and reporting requirements
- Employment and professional relationships
- Civil penalties and financial exposure
- Restrictions on future securities-related business activities
These issues should be considered as part of the defense strategy rather than treated as unrelated problems.
Early Legal Guidance Can Make a Difference
A securities investigation does not always begin with criminal charges or a formal enforcement action.
The first indication of a problem may be a subpoena, document request, regulatory examination, internal investigation or contact from government investigators.
Individuals who believe they are simply cooperating with a routine inquiry may not fully appreciate the potential implications of their responses.
Legal guidance during the early stages can help clarify the nature of the investigation, applicable obligations and possible criminal or administrative consequences.
Preserving relevant records and understanding the legal significance of requested information are important parts of responding appropriately.
One Investigation Should Not Be Allowed to Define Your Entire Future
Securities investigations can place careers, businesses, financial interests and personal freedom at risk. When criminal and regulatory issues overlap, the consequences of an individual decision may extend well beyond the proceeding in which it is made.
The Kreiss Law Firm offers criminal defense and administrative law representation informed by an understanding of these interconnected legal challenges.
Our objective is to help clients understand the allegations, evaluate the potential consequences and make informed decisions about the path forward.
Contact The Kreiss Law Firm to schedule a free consultation concerning a securities fraud investigation, regulatory enforcement matter or related criminal allegations.
Frequently Asked Questions About Securities Fraud and Regulatory Investigations
Yes. Although the SEC is a civil enforcement agency, it may refer suspected criminal violations to the Department of Justice or other law enforcement authorities. Criminal and civil investigations can also proceed simultaneously.
Yes. FINRA can pursue disciplinary action based on violations of applicable securities rules and regulations, regardless of whether criminal charges are filed or a conviction occurs.
Certain criminal convictions and other disqualifying events may affect eligibility to work in the securities industry. Criminal charges can also create disclosure obligations in particular circumstances. The consequences depend on the offense, procedural status and applicable regulations.
Yes. Civil enforcement proceedings and criminal prosecutions have different purposes and legal standards. The same underlying conduct can potentially result in both types of proceedings.
Seeking legal advice before responding is advisable, particularly when the inquiry could involve allegations of misconduct or possible criminal exposure. An attorney can help evaluate the request, explain applicable obligations and assist with an appropriate response.
Not necessarily. An SEC settlement generally does not eliminate the possibility of separate criminal proceedings. The terms and implications of a proposed settlement should be evaluated carefully before an agreement is reached.
One Investigation Should Not Be Allowed to Define Your Entire Future
Securities investigations can place careers, businesses, financial interests and personal freedom at risk. When criminal and regulatory issues overlap, the consequences of an individual decision may extend well beyond the proceeding in which it is made.
Kreiss & Butler offers criminal defense and administrative law representation informed by an understanding of these interconnected legal challenges.
Our objective is to help clients understand the allegations, evaluate the potential consequences and make informed decisions about the path forward.
Contact The Kreiss Law Firm to schedule a free consultation concerning a securities fraud investigation, regulatory enforcement matter or related criminal allegations.